Symptom scores: HBI, CDAI and questionnaires
How doctors turn 'how have you been?' into a number, what the scores mean, and why they are only part of the picture
In short
- A symptom score asks the same questions each time, so changes are easier to spot and compare.
- The Harvey-Bradshaw Index (HBI) is short and based on how you felt yesterday. Under 5 is usually counted as remission.
- The CDAI is longer. It needs a 7-day diary and a blood test, and is mainly used in research.
- Questionnaires like IBD-Control ask how well controlled your Crohn's feels and how it affects daily life.
- Symptoms and inflammation do not always match, so scores are used together with blood, poo and other tests.
On this page
What is a symptom score?
When you see your IBD team, they will ask how you have been: how often you are going to the toilet, whether you have pain, how you feel in yourself. A symptom score asks these questions in a fixed way and adds up the answers into a number. Because the questions are the same every time, it becomes easier to compare one month with the next, or one person with another.12
A patient guide from the New Zealand Society of Gastroenterology explains that doctors use these questions alongside examining you, blood and poo tests, scans and camera tests. It encourages patients to answer the same questions themselves over time. That way, changes are noticed and treatment can be started at the right time.1
How does the Harvey-Bradshaw Index work?
The Harvey-Bradshaw Index (HBI) is a widely used, internationally recognised score for Crohn's. It was published in 1980. All the questions are about how you were yesterday. It adds up points for:13
- General wellbeing: from 'very well' (0 points) to 'terrible' (4 points).
- Tummy pain: from none (0) to severe (3).
- The number of liquid or soft poos you had. The number itself is added to the score.
- A lump in your tummy that can be felt (an 'abdominal mass'): from none (0) to a definite lump that is tender (3).
- Other problems linked to Crohn's, 1 point each: painful joints, sore red eyes (such as uveitis), mouth ulcers, certain skin problems, a tear in the skin of the bottom (anal fissure), a new fistula, or an abscess.13
MDCalc, a clinical calculator site, gives these commonly used bands for the total: under 5 means remission, 5 to 7 means mild, 8 to 16 means moderate, and over 16 means severe. It also stresses that treatment decisions depend on many things, and severity is only one of them.3
The New Zealand guide suggests filling in the HBI if you think you are having a flare, and before your next appointment. It also gives one warning: if you have a painful red eye, especially if you have had eye inflammation linked to Crohn's before, get medical help urgently.1
What is the CDAI?
The Crohn's Disease Activity Index (CDAI) is an older and more detailed score. MDCalc calls it the gold standard, used in studies around the world. It needs a 7-day diary of symptoms, a blood test and your weight, as well as questions and an examination. Different parts are weighted and added together. A total under 150 is taken as remission, and over 450 as severe Crohn's.2
MDCalc points out that CDAI results can vary depending on lab blood ranges and changes in weight. The HBI is simpler because it only asks about the day before, not a whole week. In the original 1980 study, the two scores matched closely.23
What about questionnaires on how Crohn's affects my life?
Some questionnaires focus on how you feel your condition is going, rather than counting symptoms. One example developed in the UK is the IBD-Control questionnaire. It was built with input from patients and published in the journal Gut. It has 13 quick questions about the past two weeks, plus a 0 to 100 slider for how well controlled you feel your IBD is. The questions cover whether you think your treatment is working, missed activities, waking at night, low energy, pain, and feeling anxious or low. In testing, people took just over a minute to fill it in.4
Questionnaires like this are increasingly part of remote check-ups. In University Hospitals Birmingham's home monitoring service, for example, patients fill in a short online questionnaire about their symptoms, usually every three to six months. They send it with a calprotectin result, and the IBD team reviews both together.5
Why isn't a symptom score enough on its own?
How you feel and what is happening inside your bowel do not always line up. Crohn's & Colitis UK points out that a colonoscopy or biopsies can show inflammation even when you have no symptoms. Calprotectin in poo can also be raised when you feel well.6
The CALM trial, published in 2017, tested this directly in adults with early Crohn's. In one group, treatment was stepped up based on symptom scores alone. In the other, it was stepped up based on symptoms plus calprotectin and CRP. After 48 weeks, 46% of the second group had a healed bowel lining with no deep ulcers, against 30% of the symptoms-only group. The researchers concluded that combining symptoms with these markers led to better results than symptoms alone.7
That is why modern Crohn's care uses a 'treat-to-target' approach. Treatment is adjusted based on measurable signs of inflammation checked at regular intervals, not just on how you feel. Your answers still matter. Questionnaires like IBD-Control were designed to capture how well controlled Crohn's feels from your own point of view.48
Sources
This article is written in our own words from these sources. Each number in the text points to one of them.
- New Zealand Society of Gastroenterology How to complete your own Harvey-Bradshaw Index: a guide for patients with Crohn's disease Read on the New Zealand Society of Gastroenterology website: How to complete your own Harvey-Bradshaw Index: a guide for patients with Crohn's disease
- MDCalc Crohn's Disease Activity Index (CDAI) Read on the MDCalc website: Crohn's Disease Activity Index (CDAI)
- MDCalc Harvey-Bradshaw Index (HBI) for Crohn's Disease Read on the MDCalc website: Harvey-Bradshaw Index (HBI) for Crohn's Disease
- Gut (BMJ) via PubMed Central Development and validation of a rapid, generic measure of disease control from the patient's perspective: the IBD-Control questionnaire Study, Jul 2014 Read the paper: Development and validation of a rapid, generic measure of disease control from the patient's perspective: the IBD-Control questionnaire
- University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust IBD home monitoring patient information Leaflet, Oct 2024 Read the University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust leaflet: IBD home monitoring patient information
- Crohn's & Colitis UK Tests and investigations Guide, Dec 2025 Read on the Crohn's & Colitis UK website: Tests and investigations
- The Lancet Effect of tight control management on Crohn's disease (CALM): a multicentre, randomised, controlled phase 3 trial Study, Dec 2017 Read the paper: Effect of tight control management on Crohn's disease (CALM): a multicentre, randomised, controlled phase 3 trial
- Journal of Crohn's and Colitis via PubMed Central Magnetic Resonance Enterography and Intestinal Ultrasound for the Assessment and Monitoring of Crohn's Disease Systematic review, Sep 2024 Read the review: Magnetic Resonance Enterography and Intestinal Ultrasound for the Assessment and Monitoring of Crohn's Disease