Head-to-head trial

A trial that compares two active treatments directly, rather than comparing a treatment with placebo.

Also called: head to head, comparative trial, active comparator, drug vs drug

Related words non-inferiority network meta-analysis

Topics Research

Questions people ask

Which biologic is best for Crohn's?

There is no single best biologic for everyone. Trials comparing two drugs directly are still few: SEAVUE found ustekinumab and adalimumab worked about equally well in people new to biologics, and SEQUENCE found risankizumab was better than ustekinumab at healing the bowel in people for whom anti-TNF drugs had not worked. A 2026 Cochrane review comparing all the options says more head-to-head trials are needed.

Sources

How can I take part in a Crohn's clinical trial?

The NHS suggests asking your doctor or a patient organisation about trials you may be eligible for. You can also search the NIHR's Be Part of Research website for UK studies and contact research teams directly. Registries such as ISRCTN and ClinicalTrials.gov list studies and their results. Crohn's & Colitis UK explains how new medicines are tested before they are licensed.

Sources

How do I take part in Crohn's research?

Ask your IBD team whether your hospital is running any studies. You can also search the NIHR's Be Part of Research website, which lists UK studies currently recruiting people with Crohn's. The IBD BioResource invites people with Crohn's or colitis to join a national panel and be contacted about future studies. Crohn's & Colitis UK also lists ways to help shape research, such as patient and public involvement.

Sources

Can I have treatment for piles if I have Crohn's?

Piles can be treated, but surgery needs care. A 2022 review of studies on piles surgery in people with IBD found the evidence was low quality and concluded that operations in Crohn's should be done cautiously, after other treatments have failed and when the disease is inactive. The NHS describes self-care and pharmacy options for piles; talk to your IBD team before any procedure.

Sources

What is a Cochrane review and why does it matter?

Cochrane reviews are systematic reviews: researchers find every good trial on a question, judge how reliable each one is and combine the results. They also grade how certain the evidence is. For Crohn's, Cochrane has found strong evidence for some treatments, such as vedolizumab, and too little evidence to judge others, such as treatments for fatigue.

Sources

Where to read more

Ustekinumab versus adalimumab for induction and maintenance therapy in biologic-naive patients with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease (SEAVUE)

The Lancet Study Jun 2022 Patients and professionals

One of the first 'head-to-head' trials comparing two biologics directly, in people who had never had a biologic. At one year, about 65% on ustekinumab and 61% on adalimumab were in remission, a difference too small to matter. Both worked well, so the choice between them can depend on other things such as preference and how the drug is given.

Topics Biologics and newer medicines Research

Jargon explained head-to-head trial biologic-naive confidence interval

Risankizumab versus Ustekinumab for Moderate-to-Severe Crohn's Disease (SEQUENCE)

New England Journal of Medicine Study Jul 2024 Patients and professionals

A head-to-head trial in people whose Crohn's had not responded to, or who could not tolerate, anti-TNF drugs. Risankizumab (Skyrizi) was at least as good as ustekinumab (Stelara) for remission at 24 weeks and better at healing the bowel lining by 48 weeks. Side effects looked similar.

Topics Biologics and newer medicines Research

Jargon explained non-inferiority endoscopic remission anti-TNF

Biologic drugs for induction and maintenance of remission in Crohn's disease: a network meta-analysis

Cochrane Systematic review Jun 2026 Patients and professionals

An NIHR-funded Cochrane review that compares all the biologic and newer drugs for Crohn's at once, even where they were never tested against each other directly. Many, including adalimumab, risankizumab, guselkumab, upadacitinib and vedolizumab, were probably or possibly better than placebo, but the strength of evidence varied a lot. The authors say more head-to-head trials, more focus on bowel healing, and better long-term safety data are needed.

Topics Biologics and newer medicines Research

Jargon explained network meta-analysis relative risk number needed to treat biosimilar

Clinical trials

NHS Web page Dec 2022 For patients

The NHS explains what a clinical trial is and how to find one. It suggests asking your doctor or a patient organisation, and points to the Be Part of Research website, where you can search UK studies and contact researchers.

Topics Research

Jargon explained clinical trial randomised

Vedolizumab for induction and maintenance of remission in Crohn's disease

Cochrane Systematic review Jul 2023 Patients and professionals

Pooling several trials, Cochrane found high-certainty evidence that vedolizumab (Entyvio) works better than placebo both for bringing on remission and keeping it. Overall side effects were probably similar to placebo. Head-to-head comparisons with other biologics are still needed.

Topics Biologics and newer medicines Research

Jargon explained high-certainty evidence induction maintenance integrin

Effect of tight control management on Crohn's disease (CALM): a multicentre, randomised, controlled phase 3 trial

The Lancet Study Dec 2017 Patients and professionals

CALM compared deciding treatment on symptoms alone with 'tight control', where treatment was stepped up if blood or poo tests (CRP and faecal calprotectin) showed inflammation even when people felt fine. After 48 weeks, 46% in the tight control group had a healed bowel lining compared with 30% in the symptom-only group. It is a cornerstone of the 'treat to target' approach.

Topics Monitoring Biologics and newer medicines Research

Jargon explained tight control faecal calprotectin CRP mucosal healing treat to target

Be Part of Research

NIHR Tool For patients

The NHS research service's search tool for finding health studies to take part in across the UK. Searching for Crohn's disease lists studies currently recruiting, with who can join and where. A good first stop if you want to volunteer for a trial.

Topics Research

Jargon explained clinical trial recruiting

Risankizumab as induction therapy for Crohn's disease: results from the phase 3 ADVANCE and MOTIVATE induction trials

The Lancet Study May 2022 Patients and professionals

Two trials testing risankizumab (Skyrizi) drips to bring active Crohn's under control, including in people for whom other biologics had failed. Risankizumab led to more remissions, and more improvement seen on camera tests of the bowel, at 12 weeks than placebo, and was generally well tolerated.

Topics Biologics and newer medicines

Jargon explained induction phase 3 trial endoscopic response

A biomarker-stratified comparison of top-down versus accelerated step-up treatment strategies for patients with newly diagnosed Crohn's disease (PROFILE)

The Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology Study May 2024 Patients and professionals

A large UK-led trial of 386 newly diagnosed adults. Starting straight away with infliximab plus an immunosuppressant ('top-down') kept 79% in remission without steroids or surgery for a year, compared with 15% using the usual 'step-up' approach of trying milder drugs first. There were also fewer flares, serious side effects and operations. A blood test meant to predict who needed strong treatment did not help. Free to read in full.

Topics Biologics and newer medicines Research About Crohn's disease

Jargon explained top-down treatment step-up treatment biomarker steroid-free remission top-down step-up immunomodulator randomised controlled trial

Infliximab, azathioprine, or combination therapy for Crohn's disease (SONIC)

New England Journal of Medicine Study Apr 2010 Patients and professionals

A landmark trial of 508 adults with moderate to severe Crohn's who had never had immunosuppressants or biologics. Infliximab and azathioprine together worked best: about 57% were in remission without steroids at 26 weeks, against 44% on infliximab alone and 30% on azathioprine alone. This is why many people starting infliximab are offered a second 'helper' drug alongside it.

Topics Biologics and newer medicines Immunosuppressants Research

Jargon explained combination therapy steroid-free remission mucosal healing randomised controlled trial

Search everything for "head-to-head trial"